Question:
Is it the intent of chapter R611.2 to disallow a stilt house to be consrtucted of a masonry columned ground level with 2 stories of ICF above Comment: We have designed a residence with a 2 story living area whose exterior walls are constructed of ICF sittiing on a series of masonry columns and precast concrete and masonry beams. this would seem to be only two stories of ICF above ground.
Answer on 07/12/2007 at 9:38 AM
Yes, without proper engineering evaluation. Please see the
attached commentary.
Commentary:
The described structure would not be permitted if solely
designed using the prescriptive design contained in the
code, because it is a three story structure. As stated in
the code commentary for the section, ICF construction
outside the precriptive code limitations would require an
engineered design.
The two primary areas of concern would be floor loads and
the increased wind pressure if the building mean roof
height exceeds 35 feet with a tributary area of 10 sq. ft.
If the design provided a design professional evaluation of
the floor loads; including: the loads of the floor
diaphragm and the ability of the wall structure to accept
the diaphragm loads; any increase in the loads on walls
due to the building exceeding a mean roof height of 35
feet; and, the loads on the pile foundation, it should be
acceptable. During discussion of the issues with the
principal author of the provisions, it was agreed there
may be some increased loads which would merit the
evaluation and justification, particularly in the higher
wind zones.